Before the flop you have three options: fold, call, raise.

The 3-bet post is about whether you pick the rightmost one often enough. This post is about the middle one — the option you take without thinking and without counting.

It is far too easy to pick. Somebody opens, you look down at KJs, folding feels like a waste, and raising means working out what you do when they 4-bet. The middle option neatly removes both problems.

But what it removes is the thinking, not the cost. Folding costs nothing at all; calling means matching their raise in full — you have paid, and you still have not decided anything. You think you bought the right to see a flop. What you bought is a pot with no initiative and usually no position, containing a player who acts before you with a stronger range than yours.

What is this number for? One sentence: it is your should-have-folded counter.

A cold call can only happen from four seats (the next section explains why), and in RushCraft’s default ranges only one of those four seats ever takes it: the button. MP, CO and SB never call an open; they 3-bet or fold. This post covers what it costs, why position decides who may call, what the button’s list looks like, how the number on RushCraft’s stage 3 differs from the cold-call rate, and how large a sample it takes before it counts. Read VPIP and 3-bet first if you have not.

Which of Your Calls It Counts

“Cold” means you have not voluntarily put a chip in this round.

Calling a raise from the big blind does not count — your blind is already on the table and you are only topping up the difference. Calling a cutoff open from the button does count: you start from zero and put the whole raise in cold, all at once.

The numerator is “you called”. The denominator is “you had the chance to call”. Four conditions have to hold at once, and they are the ones RushCraft actually applies when parsing hand histories:

You face exactly one raise, that raise was not yours, you have not voluntarily put money in this round, and you are not in the big blind.

So it only accumulates in four seats: MP, CO, BTN and SB. From UTG there is nobody in front of you to call; limping and then calling does not count (that is a limp-call, a different leak); calling after two raises does not count either (that is a different number).

Excluding the big blind entirely is deliberate, because it is a fundamentally different thing: your money is already in, the price difference is the smallest at the table, your position is fixed and the worst there is, and nobody behind you can squeeze. Averaging it in gives you a number that is wrong about both. Which hands the big blind should defend against an open is a separate table: RushCraft’s stage 4, BB Defense Range, counts opens from all five seats and looks at how often you call or re-raise with hands outside the defence range, with a target of 10% or less.

You Paid, and What You Bought Is Three Disadvantages

The difference between calling and 3-betting is not how much money goes in, it is who gets to define the pot — the 3-bet post covers that. A cold call carries three costs on top of an ordinary call, and they only apply while the call is cold.

First, your range is capped from the outset.

Your genuinely good hands went into 3-bets, so the ceiling of a cold-calling range is always pushed down. Take RushCraft’s default list for the button: the top of it is TT, AJs and KQs — no AA, KK, QQ or JJ, and no AK or AQ. Your opponent does not need to be a genius to know this. So when the flop comes ace-high or king-high, he can keep betting in complete comfort, because the strongest hands you could have simply do not exist.

A capped range can only defend after the flop, never counter-attack. This is the most expensive cost of a cold call, and the hardest one to notice.

Second, you invited the players behind you in.

Your call makes the pot bigger, which makes the price better for everyone behind. The button who would have folded T9s can now call, because of the money you added. You spent money improving somebody else’s pot odds — and now you play a flop against two opponents, from the middle seat.

There is a more direct version of this: the squeeze. An opener, you, and three or four players yet to act is the single best spot at the table for a squeeze, and you are the person who made squeezing profitable. When you get squeezed, folding is very nearly your only option (your range is capped and cannot take it), and the money you called with is gone.

Third, the price is worse than you think.

In the big blind, calling a 3bb open costs you 2bb more to see the flop. Here it costs you 3bb. Same hand, same flop, 50% higher cost. A lot of players build their calling habits in the big blind and then carry them, unchanged, into every other seat — this is the most common source of a high cold-call rate, more common than simply liking to play hands.

Why Only the Button Cold Calls

The first and third costs are much the same from every seat: any call caps your range, and every seat has to put the whole raise in. The difference lies in two things — how many players are still to act behind you, and whether anyone acts after you once the flop is down. How many are behind you is the size of the second cost: how big the risk of being squeezed, or of inviting people in, is. Who acts after you on the flop decides whether, having paid, you can actually play the hand out.

Your position Still to act behind you After the flop Default cold-calling list
MP 4 (CO, BTN, SB, BB) If CO or BTN calls too, someone acts after you None
CO 3 (BTN, SB, BB) If BTN calls too, it acts after you None
BTN 2 (SB, BB) Whoever comes in, you act last 44-TT, A8s-AJs, KTs+, QTs+, JTs
SB 1 (BB) You act first on every street None

The button is the only seat where both things are on your side. Only the two blinds are left behind you, and after the flop they act before you, just as the opener does. What your call buys is the last action of the hand: on every street you see what everyone else did before you decide, you can take a free card when you miss, and you can choose how big the pot gets when you hit. A capped range can only be played because of that. None of this makes the button risk-free: the two blinds can still re-raise and squeeze you, and the button does not get to call with many hands either — its list is only 6.2% (next section).

The cutoff is only one seat short of the button, but that seat is the one that matters most. Directly behind you sits the button, the best seat at the table both for calling along and for squeezing. If it calls, you play the flop stuck between the opener and the button (why you should not call in the middle covers exactly that spot in its third section); if it re-raises, your capped range cannot take it.

Middle position is the same thing with one more player behind. Four players are still to act, and the only open it ever faces comes from UTG, the tightest range at the table. If all four fold, you play the flop against a range stronger than yours; if someone calls along or squeezes, it only gets worse.

The small blind is the reverse: only one player behind, and the worst position there is. When the big blind sees your call, he gets the best price at the table to come along, or to re-raise behind you; after the flop you act first on every street, with the opener and the big blind both after you. Having few players behind is cancelled out by having no position on any street. And the opens the small blind faces most often come from wide-opening seats like the cutoff and the button, where a re-raise gets folds often — income a 3-bet collects and a call never does.

So what position decides is not how much you call, it is whether anything offsets the cost of calling. Only the button has that, which is why in RushCraft’s default ranges only the button has a cold-calling list; MP, CO and SB never call an open by default. Not calling is not the same as not playing: those three seats still enter the pot, with a 3-bet — the rightmost option, which the 3-bet post is about.

The Ceiling: 6.2% on the Button, 0 Everywhere Else, and No Floor

Put the previous section into numbers and you get this line:

Your position Ceiling
BTN 6.2%
MP, CO, SB 0% (facing an open, only 3-bet or fold)

The button’s 6.2% is worked out from its list (below). MP, CO and SB have no list, so their line sits at 0: every call of an open is one call over.

Start with the thing that is not written there: this number has no lower bound.

Most statistics on the site are an interval, where too low and too high are both leaks — VPIP at 18-25%, 3-bet at 6-12%, ATS with a band per position. Cold call is not like that: a player who never cold calls, who 3-bets what should be 3-bet and folds the rest, has nothing wrong with him. He may give up a little marginal value, but he is not bleeding. Calling is not an action worth a frequency; it is an exception that is profitable under specific conditions — which is why this line only runs in one direction, and why from three seats it is simply 0.

Which hands the button is actually meant to call with

Facing an open from UTG, MP or CO, RushCraft’s defaults give the button a cold-calling list for each opener, and all three lists are the same. Put it next to the 3-bet table for the same spot and you have the button’s complete answer to an open:

Opener 3-bet Call (the cold-calling list) Together
UTG, MP JJ+, AQs+, AQo+ 44-TT, A8s-AJs, KTs+, QTs+, JTs (6.2%) 10.4%
CO JJ+, AQs+, ATo+, KQo Same as above (6.2%) 13.1%

Everything else is a fold.

The list in full is 17 squares: seven pairs from 44 to TT, plus ten suited hands, A8s, A9s, ATs, AJs, KQs, KJs, KTs, QJs, QTs and JTs. A pair is 6 combinations and a suited hand 4, which makes 82 combinations out of 1,326, or 6.2%.

Three things there are worth a look.

First, there is not a single offsuit hand on the list. Big offsuit hands like AQo, AJo and KQo either go into a 3-bet or into the muck; they never appear in the calling column. The reason is condition two in the fifth section: hands that make top pair without knowing whether they are outkicked are where cold calling loses the most money.

Second, the wider the opener, the more you 3-bet, but the list does not change. Against a cutoff open the 3-bet table gains AJo, ATo and KQo — hands that are folds against UTG and MP, not hands taken off the list. So the share you continue with goes from 10.4% to 13.1%, and all of the extra is 3-bets. When your opponent’s range widens, the answer is initiative, not more calls.

Third, the ceiling is the list itself. The list and the 3-bet tables do not share a single hand, so if you call every time the list says call and 3-bet every time the 3-bet table says so, your cold-call rate lands right on 6.2%.

A hand being on the list does not make this hand a call

So every call outside the list is over the ceiling. The reverse does not hold: a hand being on the list does not make every instance of it a call. The ceiling is a ceiling, not a target.

One hand makes the point fastest. You are on the button, the cutoff opens, you have 55 — a hand on the list, and not in the 3-bet range. But at this table today, the man in the small blind re-raises the moment he sees anybody call. This hand is a fold, and the list will never tell you that.

Because the list only knows two things: where you are sitting and what you were dealt. It cannot see who is behind you, whether your opponent pays off after the flop, or how many chips you have left. Get any one of those three wrong and a hand on the list becomes a hand to fold.

So: the list says which hands are eligible to be considered a call. The ceiling is the most you should call. This line has no floor, so whatever calls are cut away by what is actually happening at this table today, cutting them is always safe. The five conditions in the next section are how you cut.

When a Cold Call Is Not Laziness

The sections so far are all about what it costs. But the button’s line is not zero, which means there are times when it is right. Five conditions: the more of them hold, the more this is a call. With only one or two, go back to 3-betting or folding.

One: you have position, and there are not many players left behind you.

On the button facing a cutoff open, only two blinds are left to act. In middle position facing an UTG open, there are four players behind. The same KTs is a call in the first case and a fold in the second. The hand did not get weaker; every extra player still to act is one more player who can 3-bet you out of the pot — and if they merely call instead, you have more opponents to handle after the flop. The table in the third section is this condition: only on the button do both parts of it hold.

Two: your hand is the kind that lets go when it misses, not the kind that gets stuck halfway there.

This is about hand type, not hand strength:

  • Pairs and suited big cards: easy to recognise when they make a set or a flush, and easy to release when they do not. They run on implied odds — the full arithmetic is in how to work out pot odds. The button’s default list is exactly these two kinds: 44 to TT, plus suited aces, kings, queens and jacks
  • Big offsuit hands like AJo and KJo: when they make top pair you cannot tell whether you are ahead or outkicked, and there is no second way to win. This is where cold calling loses the most money; these hands belong in a 3-bet or a fold

Three: the stacks are deep enough.

Set-mining with a small pair hits about one time in eight, so the pot you win back has to be big enough to justify it. With forty big blinds behind, the “hit it and win a fortune” story never gets told — with no implied odds, cold calling a small pair is just throwing a chip in the water every time.

Four: your opponent will not let go just because you 3-bet.

A 3-bet earns most of its money in the instant the other player folds. Against the kind of player who calls with anything he liked enough to play, and calls your 3-bet too, that income drops to zero — and 3-betting a medium hand into him just builds a big pot as a gift. Against that player, calling is correct: you get a cheap look at a flop, and when you hit he pays.

Five: the opener’s range is tight.

An UTG open means his range was strong to begin with. Re-raise with TT from the button and you run into a bigger pair a good share of the time, and he is not folding — against a tight opening range, the fold equity and the hand-strength edge in a 3-bet disappear together. Calling to see a flop is reasonable here. The button’s defaults are laid out the same way: against UTG, TT is on the list and the 3-bets start at JJ.

Turned around, those five conditions are a self-check. Before your next cold call, count how many of them hold. If you cannot count one, that was not a decision. That was laziness.

From MP, CO and SB, the first condition fails before you start, which is why the default there is never to call. If the other four really do line up at a particular table — deep stacks, a tight opener, and a player who never lets go to a 3-bet — calling can be right. Just know that it is a departure from the default, and RushCraft’s stage 3 will count it as a mistake (section seven).

Reading Opponents: What a High Cold Caller Is

Everything so far has been your own number. Flipped around, a high cold-call rate on the player across the table is one of the most welcome signals you can get.

Cold calling is the largest component of the gap between VPIP and PFR. Take a player with VPIP 30 and PFR 12: how does the money in those 18 percentage points get into the pot? Mostly by calling — limping, and cold calling. That gap is not an abstract personality sketch. It has a specific source.

When you see a high cold caller, three things follow:

What he does How you change
He enters with a pile of marginal hands, so his range is wide and capped You can open a little wider, because he will call with worse than you
Once he calls he struggles to let go after the flop Cut the bluffs and size your value bets up. Bluffing someone who does not fold is a pure loss
He cold calls in front of you with players still to act This is the ideal squeeze spot. The opener is wide, the caller is capped, and neither can stand a big re-raise

That last row is worth remembering: somebody else’s cold call is your opportunity. The second section said a cold call invites people in to squeeze you. Here you are the one being invited.

RushCraft’s Stage 3: Every Decision, Not the Cold-Call Rate

Of RushCraft’s five preflop stages, the one closest to cold calling is stage 3, Facing a Raise. But its number and the cold-call rate do not count the same thing.

The cold-call rate counts how often you called. The denominator is the opportunities the four conditions in the first section produce, and the numerator is how many times you pressed call, whether or not that hand should have been called.

Stage 3 counts how often you were wrong. It looks at every decision MP, CO, BTN and SB make facing one raise (exactly one player has raised and nobody has called), and folds, calls and 3-bets all go into the denominator. Two kinds of decision count as mistakes:

  • A call that should not have been made: from MP, CO and SB any call is a mistake, whatever the hand; on the button, calling with a hand off the list is a mistake — and so is flatting a hand that belongs in the 3-bet table, like JJ or AQs
  • A 3-bet outside the range: a 3-bet with a hand that is not in the 3-bet table for that matchup is a mistake, including a button 3-bet with 88, a hand from the list

A fold is never a mistake, and the target is 3% or less.

Two ways of playing side by side make the difference clearest:

How you play Cold-call rate Stage 3
Exactly to the default ranges, every hand About 6.2% on the button, 0 elsewhere 0%
Never call, but keep 3-betting hands outside the 3-bet tables 0% Not 0

So the cold-call rate is a description: how often you take the middle option. Stage 3 is a verdict: how far the options you take facing a raise are from the default ranges.

You can see both. The cold-call rate is in Detailed Stats, as a single number for the four seats together: the button’s 6.2% and everyone else’s 0 are mixed into it, so it cannot tell you which seat you call too much from. It can tell you one thing: if the total is above 6.2%, at least one seat is over its line. Stage 3 is in Training Progress, with numbers per seat and a button to practise it; the practice puts you in the spot of facing one open and has you choose between fold, call and 3-bet, and the answers are the table in the fourth section plus each seat’s 3-bet tables.

To find out which hands, use Add Filter on the main screen and tick Cold Call to pull up every hand you cold called: every one that is not on the button is a call outside the default ranges, and the button ones you check against the list in the fourth section. Actually looking at those hands is far more useful than looking at a percentage — your cold calls will mostly cluster in two or three situations, and ten hands is enough to see the pattern.

Sample Size: 50 Opportunities Resolve to Two Percentage Points

How large a sample does the cold-call rate need before it counts? First, how fast opportunities accumulate. The conditions are slightly stricter than 3-bet’s (you have to be in one of MP, CO, BTN or SB, facing exactly one raise), which works out at roughly 20 opportunities per 100 hands across the four seats, or about 5 per seat. So it takes around 1,000 hands for one seat to collect 50 opportunities.

MP, CO and SB first: those three seats have no use for the table below. Their line is at 0, so every call is one call over, and you do not need statistics to tell you whether you crossed it — every hand the filter in the previous section pulls up away from the button is one. The sample question only arises on the button.

Take the button, with a true cold call sitting exactly on its list’s 6.2%:

Opportunities Roughly how many hands Observed number lands at What that interval is good for
50 ~1,000 0% – 13% Catching only the outrageous
200 ~4,000 3% – 10% Obvious excess becomes visible
500 ~10,000 4% – 8% You can start saying high or not high
2,000 ~40,000 5% – 7% Only now is fine-tuning meaningful

(Normal approximation of the 95% interval; the orders of magnitude are right.)

The first row is the point, and there is a blunter way to say it: at 50 opportunities the resolution is two percentage points — one extra call moves the number by 2%. Meanwhile the button’s line is at 6.2%. On a 50-opportunity sample you cannot tell which side of the line you are on.

So what are 50 opportunities good for? The leak this number is really hunting is not “6.5 or 5.9”, it is the player at 20% or 25%. That level is unmistakable at 50 opportunities, and how wide the interval is makes no difference to the conclusion.

The right way to use cold call is therefore bracketing, not tuning:

  • 50 to 200 opportunities: confirm whether you are abusing it. Anything past 20% is a conclusion already; no more data required
  • Around 500: put yourself in the normal or high bracket, then cut using the five conditions in the fifth section
  • Past ten thousand hands: only now does “6 or 7” apply — and frankly that question is not worth much, because this number has no floor and going down is always safe

Stage 3 has a sample rule too: it waits for your last 200 decisions facing a raise before it gives a verdict, and between 50 and 199 it shows only a grey reference number. It counts the four seats together but leaves out hands where someone has already called, so it collects a little more slowly than cold-call opportunities; at a rough 20 per 100 hands, a little over a thousand hands is enough to reach 200.

If You Play Rush & Cash

On fast-fold tables, folding moves you to a new table, and that affects cold call more than any other statistic — in the direction of tightening.

The reason is in the fifth section’s five conditions: you cannot verify the fourth or the fifth. “This opponent will not let go to a 3-bet” and “this player’s opening range is tight” both require a read, and on a fast-fold table you never play ten hands against the same person, so no read ever accumulates. A condition you cannot verify is a condition you cannot assume, so cold calling on fast-fold tables should be narrower than at a fixed table, with the marginal hands going out to the 3-bet and fold sides.

There is an upside the other way: the opportunities accumulate quickly. At about 20 per 100 hands across the four seats, fast-fold speed makes the eighth section’s 500 opportunities on the button (roughly ten thousand hands) a reachable number. The way to do it is to export your hand history from PokerCraft first (six steps, see downloading your Natural8 hand history); import it into RushCraft and your cold-call rate is already computed, and stage 3, Facing a Raise, is judged again on the same hands. To see which hands are producing it, pull them up with the filter.


Cold call comes down to one sentence: facing an open, how often you choose the button that decides nothing.

  • The denominator: exactly one raise faced, no voluntary money in yet this round, and not the big blind. In practice it only accumulates in MP, CO, BTN and SB
  • The thing that is missing: this line has a ceiling and no floor. Calling is not an action worth a frequency, and too little has never been a leak
  • The three costs: a capped range, the players you invite in behind you (and the squeeze), and a price 50% worse than the big blind’s
  • Position: only on the button are just two blinds left behind and do you always act last after the flop, so only there does something offset the cost of calling. That is why in RushCraft’s defaults only the button has a list; MP, CO and SB never call an open, they 3-bet or fold
  • Where the ceiling comes from: the button’s list is 44-TT, A8s-AJs, KTs+, QTs+, JTs, 82 combinations or 6.2%, with no overlap with the 3-bet tables; MP, CO and SB are 0. Play the list and you land on the line; every call outside it is over
  • The gap between the list and the table: the list only knows where you sit and what you hold, not who is behind you, whether he pays off, or how deep you are — whatever calls those three things cut away, cutting them is always safe
  • The five conditions: position, a hand type that can let go, deep enough stacks, an opponent who cannot be pushed off, a tight opener. Cannot count one, and it was laziness
  • The two numbers: the cold-call rate counts how often you called; stage 3, Facing a Raise, counts how often you were wrong facing a raise (a call that should not have been made, a 3-bet outside the range). Play to the default ranges and the first is about 6.2% on the button while the second is 0
  • The sample: 50 opportunities resolve to two percentage points, enough only for the outrageous; MP, CO and SB need no sample, since every call is one over. Bracket, do not tune

Next time somebody opens in front of you and your hand is neither strong nor trash — do not reach for the middle option yet. Ask yourself whether you are making a decision, or postponing one.

Folding is free. Postponing is not.